237
edits
Difference between revisions of "User talk:Moydow"
no edit summary
| Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
:# It's always a good idea to have an independent review of an article. On StrategyWiki, the system is to allow a guide's contributors decide its completion level (between levels 1 and 4). Featured guides (level 5) are voted on by the community, and it's often the only point where a guide gets a good thorough review by others. So I'd be favourable to the system you propose. A good idea is to get reviews from increasingly external sources as a page gets closer to featured status. If you'd like, I could help with some of the reviewing, as most of what I do focuses on reviewing edits for quality, and generally keeping pages in order. | :# It's always a good idea to have an independent review of an article. On StrategyWiki, the system is to allow a guide's contributors decide its completion level (between levels 1 and 4). Featured guides (level 5) are voted on by the community, and it's often the only point where a guide gets a good thorough review by others. So I'd be favourable to the system you propose. A good idea is to get reviews from increasingly external sources as a page gets closer to featured status. If you'd like, I could help with some of the reviewing, as most of what I do focuses on reviewing edits for quality, and generally keeping pages in order. | ||
: [[User:Moydow|<font color="green">Moy</font>]][[User talk:Moydow|<font color="orange">dow</font>]] 13:42, 13 September 2010 (PDT) | : [[User:Moydow|<font color="green">Moy</font>]][[User talk:Moydow|<font color="orange">dow</font>]] 13:42, 13 September 2010 (PDT) | ||
::# the idea behind the box is to imitate, but not duplicate, the header seen on wikipedia [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Star_Fox_(series) discussion pages]. And thank you, i will continue to try it out. | ::# the idea behind the box is to imitate, but not duplicate, the header seen on wikipedia [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Star_Fox_(series) discussion pages]. And thank you, i will continue to try it out. | ||
::# I would strongly appreciate your help in reviewing articles. Do you understand the rules as they stand, and if so, which level do you think you would be best at? {{User:Tacopill/sig}} 14:08, 13 September 2010 (PDT). | ::# I would strongly appreciate your help in reviewing articles. Do you understand the rules as they stand, and if so, which level do you think you would be best at? {{User:Tacopill/sig}} 14:08, 13 September 2010 (PDT). | ||
:::# Never saw those before. | :::# Never saw those before. | ||
:::# The rules make sense to me. According to those, I qualify as a "good-level" reviewer. This said, my knowledge of the Star Fox games is minimal, so I probably should stick to lower levels for now. [[User:Moydow|<font color="green">Moy</font>]][[User talk:Moydow|<font color="orange">dow</font>]] 14:27, 13 September 2010 (PDT) | :::# The rules make sense to me. According to those, I qualify as a "good-level" reviewer. This said, my knowledge of the Star Fox games is minimal, so I probably should stick to lower levels for now. [[User:Moydow|<font color="green">Moy</font>]][[User talk:Moydow|<font color="orange">dow</font>]] 14:27, 13 September 2010 (PDT) | ||
::::# Ah well, thank you anyway. | ::::# Ah well, thank you anyway. | ||
::::# Would you be interested in being a [[Lylat_Wiki:Decent_Articles#To_Become_a_Decent_Article|decent]]-level reviewer or a [[Lylat_Wiki:Stubs#To_Become_a_Stub_Article|stub]]-level one? {{User:Tacopill/sig}} 16:33, 13 September 2010 (PDT). | ::::# Would you be interested in being a [[Lylat_Wiki:Decent_Articles#To_Become_a_Decent_Article|decent]]-level reviewer or a [[Lylat_Wiki:Stubs#To_Become_a_Stub_Article|stub]]-level one? {{User:Tacopill/sig}} 16:33, 13 September 2010 (PDT). | ||
:I think I'll try decent-level. [[User:Moydow|<font color="green">Moy</font>]][[User talk:Moydow|<font color="orange">dow</font>]] 16:41, 13 September 2010 (PDT) | :I think I'll try decent-level. [[User:Moydow|<font color="green">Moy</font>]][[User talk:Moydow|<font color="orange">dow</font>]] 16:41, 13 September 2010 (PDT) | ||
| Line 67: | Line 67: | ||
:::: Tacopill fixed the template, is it decent now? Foxdude54 14:52 EST, 15 October 2010 | :::: Tacopill fixed the template, is it decent now? Foxdude54 14:52 EST, 15 October 2010 | ||
:::::@Moydow: when you think it is finished, please replace {{tl|Character-stub-level v2.0}} with {{tl|Character-decent-level v2.0}}. | :::::@Moydow: when you think it is finished, please replace {{tl|Character-stub-level v2.0}} with {{tl|Character-decent-level v2.0}}. | ||
:::::@Fox dude: I am currently storing all "Stub Level" articles [[:Category:Stub-Level Articles|here]]. Please inform Moydow of any other Articles you think are ready for his review (and myself, if they are currently not protected). | :::::@Fox dude: I am currently storing all "Stub Level" articles [[:Category:Stub-Level Articles|here]]. Please inform Moydow of any other Articles you think are ready for his review (and myself, if they are currently not protected). | ||
:::::@Myself: Get busy promoting Start-level articles to stub-level for review. | :::::@Myself: Get busy promoting Start-level articles to stub-level for review. | ||
:::::{{User:Tacopill/sig}} 12:09, 15 October 2010 (PDT). | :::::{{User:Tacopill/sig}} 12:09, 15 October 2010 (PDT). | ||
::::: Sounds like a plan. Foxdude54 14:13 EST, 15 October 2010 | ::::: Sounds like a plan. Foxdude54 14:13 EST, 15 October 2010 | ||
== Peppy/Decency == | |||
First of all, I think Peppy Hare should be considered for being upgrade, and secondly, we should probably find another place for people to put their suggestion ideas. Foxdude54 14:20 EST, 15 October 2010 | |||